Saratoga Springs, New York, renowned for its vibrant nightlife and rich cultural scene, has also been identified as the state’s “drunkest” city, with 24% of its adult population reportedly engaging in excessive drinking. This high rate of alcohol consumption correlates with significant DWI statistics in the area. With high statistics, it ranks as one of New York’s top counties for such incidents. DWI is still a serious crime in many places and is punishable by less severe penalties for those convicted. But not every accused gets convicted.
Understanding the most common defenses is crucial when facing DWI charges in Saratoga Springs. A skilled Saratoga Springs DWI lawyer may challenge the legality of the traffic stop, question the accuracy of breathalyzer or field sobriety tests, or argue that medical conditions affected the test results. Employing these defense strategies can significantly impact the outcome of a DWI case, potentially leading to reduced charges or even dismissal. Thus, understanding these strategies could be the difference between being found guilty and not guilty.
Challenging the Traffic Stop
One of the most popular defenses in DWI cases is the legality of the stop. The officer must also have reasonable suspicion when stopping a vehicle. Evidence may be ruled inadmissible if there was no basis for the officer to stop the motorist. This defense relies more on examining what the officer did and whether that initially exceeded what the Constitution allowed.
The Legitimacy of Field Sobriety Tests
Many times, the arrest comes right after passing or failing those (field sobriety) tests as part of a DWI. Nevertheless, these tests are not a silver bullet. However, numerous factors, such as bad weather, irregular road conditions, or medical circumstances, can impair performance. Disputing the reliability of these tests could weaken the case for prosecution against you. If the tests are not administered properly or are simply unreliable, that can be grounds for dismissal or a lesser charge.
Challenging the Accuracy of Breathalyzer
Blood alcohol concentration (BAC) is typically measured using portable breathalyzer devices. However, they can be inaccurate due to several factors. Results can be incorrect in breath alcohol tests due to calibration errors, misuse, or even some medical conditions. Successful defenses may rely on demonstrating that the device was defective or that the operator was not competently trained. This can seriously hamper the prosecution’s case as the courtroom will begin to question the accuracy of the breathalyzer.
Conditions and Medicines
Some medical conditions or medications may be similar to the effects of alcohol and may make you intoxicated. For example, diabetes has symptoms similar to alcohol impairment. Additionally, certain medications can cause false positives in a breathalyzer test. If your behavior was misinterpreted as intoxication, evidence of these conditions can help explain your behavior. This defense highlights the need to consider alternative interpretations of apparent impairment.
Rising BAC Defense
Alcohol does not enter the bloodstream intravenously. A person’s BAC may have been above the legal limit while driving, but it went down once they got home. This is called the phenomenon of rising blood alcohol. It indicates that the BAC at the test time does not represent the degree while driving the car. This defense involves eliciting expert testimony regarding how alcohol is absorbed.
Improper Police Procedures
Law enforcement officers must follow strict procedures when handling DWI cases. They can use any protocol deviation as a defense. From neglecting to notify the accused of their rights to mistakes in gathering evidence, procedural errors can compromise the strength of the prosecution. If a person is arrested and charged with a crime, law enforcement errors may reduce the charges or even cause the case to be dismissed.
Mistaken Identity
In these cases, mistaken identity can be a defense if multiple drivers or similar vehicles exist. The defense may concede that the defendant was guilty of the underlying offense but claim someone else was behind the wheel that day. Videos or witness testimonies that confirm someone else was present at the place can help as proof of mistaken identity. This defense involves verifying the driver’s identity before charges can be filed.
Lack of Probable Cause
A legal arrest entails probable cause. Any actions following this would be unlawful if they were done with insufficient evidence to justify the arrest. Attacking the existence of probable cause can also weaken the prosecution’s case. This defense involves exploring the background circumstances of the arrest and inquiring whether the officer had a legitimate basis to move forward.
To Sum Up
Dealing with a DWI charge can be an intimidating process. While little can be done to avoid the charges, knowing the common defenses might give you a route to fight them. Employing tactics such as challenging the legality behind a traffic stop, disputing the accuracy of the tests, or mentioning medical conditions can provide options to the accused. Not all these defenses will apply to all circumstances, and having skilled lawyers means they will choose the correct defense.
People also read this: The Importance of Using the Correct Materials and Parts for a Construction Job