Is the Mini Hatch reliable?
Overall the Mini is a reliable, well built small car that shouldn’t cause you any major problems. Indeed, it is not totally free from mechanical gremlins, but by now any recalls will have been addressed and dealers, as well as independent specialists, are familar with the issues that might afflict them.
For more peace of mind, the Mini Hatch ranked fifth out of 19 cars in the small car class in the latest What Car? Reliability Survey, with an impressive overall rating of 97.9%.
Engine: Be wary of Cooper S Minis built between 2014 and 2015: a recall was issued to repair a defective crankshaft bearing and engines were either rebuilt or replaced. Check that the whole engine has been replaced because other parts may have been damaged by the faulty crankshaft.
High oil consumption is common on hotter models so check oil levels and make sure the car is serviced every year.
Exhaust: Ensure the Pro exhaust on the JCW cars is fitted properly. You’ll know it isn’t if the heat shield is rattling underneath the car.
Suspension: Listen out for a knocking noise from the front suspension as the control arm bushings like to make a racket when they’re worn. A new bushing is around £30.
Body: Door seal rubber can rub away the paint on the inside so check for any damage. You can buy door-shut paint protection film to stop the issue from recurring.
Check for clouding in the wing mirrors. New glass is around £20.
Interior: Don’t be surprised if the dashboard rattles, especially on higher-mileage cars. A creaky sunroof isn’t uncommon either and some lubricant around the seal can assuage the issue.
Check that the heated seats work and that the light doesn’t go out on the dashboard when they’re switched on. If they’re faulty, then it could be either the heat element or control module that’s to blame.
An owner’s view
Rachel Lowe: “I was looking for a step up from my 2013 ‘R56’ Cooper and the F56 model was what I was hoping for in terms of reliability and performance. In the end, I bought a 2016 JCW from Scotland and the seven-hour drive home proved that this was the right car for me. It’s very responsive, handles superbly and is surprisingly economical on longer journeys. I’ve added a few modifications, including a wrap, JCW Pro exhaust, front splitter/side skirts and the JCW Pro suspension kit. It’s been very reliable and easily the most fun car I’ve ever owned.”
Also worth knowing
If you want the fastest version of the F56-gen Mini, your best bet is the John Cooper Works GP, launched in 2020. This track-focused hot hatch is an absolute riot to drive thanks to its lowered suspension, larger brakes and 302bhp turbocharged motor.
There are plenty of special editions to choose from, such as the 1499GT, a play on the 1275GT of the original car. There’s also the 1to6 Edition, a limited-run version of the JCW that was the last Mini to feature a manual gearbox.