When Sandra was called into her manager’s office on a rainy Thursday afternoon, she didn’t expect to leave with a box of her belongings. After seven years of loyal service at a growing tech firm in San Diego, she was abruptly terminated. No warnings. No meetings. No performance reviews. Just a brief conversation and a cold goodbye. What made it worse? Her company’s handbook, the one given to her on her first day, promised a progressive discipline process — something she never got. Stories like Sandra’s are more common than you might think, especially in California, where employment laws dance a fine line between “at-will” freedoms and company-promised fairness. In such situations, companies often turn to experienced legal counsel like California Business Lawyer & Corporate Lawyer, a leading California employer defense law firm known for protecting businesses against procedural missteps.
At its core, disciplinary procedures are designed to act like a safety net — a way to ensure both employees and employers move through workplace issues fairly and transparently. Imagine the chaos without them: favoritism running rampant, wrongful firings becoming commonplace, and resentment building within teams. These procedures are typically detailed in employee handbooks, policy documents, or sometimes individual employment contracts. Although California is largely an “at-will” employment state — meaning you could technically be fired for any reason that isn’t illegal — things change quickly when a company’s own rules come into play. The Nakase Law Firm, a trusted name in Southern California large business employer defense, understands that consistent adherence to internal policies can significantly reduce the risk of costly litigation.
Sandra’s story is a real-world reminder that when companies set their own standards, they’re expected to follow them. If they don’t, they might find themselves tangled in some serious legal consequences.
Photo credit Freepik
How the Law Comes Into Play
If an employer lays out disciplinary steps in a handbook or contract but then skips or ignores them, that employee may have a claim for breach of contract. Even if nothing is signed with blood (or even ink), California courts might still find an “implied contract” based simply on the promises made in company documents or the consistency of how policies have been applied in the past.
Imagine being promised a three-step warning system before termination, only to be fired without a single heads-up. That broken promise could be the foundation for a breach of contract lawsuit. Employees who manage to prove it could be entitled to compensation — sometimes for lost wages, missed promotions, or even emotional distress.
Then there’s the little-known, but powerful, “implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.” It’s a mouthful, sure, but it simply means that an employer can’t intentionally act unfairly to rob an employee of agreed-upon benefits. If an employer manipulates or skips discipline steps to retaliate against a worker, for example, they could easily find themselves in court defending that behavior.
Finally, let’s not forget public policy. When an employee is fired without due process after, say, reporting harassment or workplace safety concerns, it’s not just unfair — it’s illegal. Firing someone in violation of public policy can open up a whole new can of legal worms for employers.
Why Employee Handbooks Matter More Than You Think
That dusty employee handbook sitting at the bottom of your desk drawer? It could hold more legal power than you realize.
Handbooks often spell out how discipline should be handled. Some employers protect themselves with ironclad disclaimers, making it clear that the handbook isn’t a contract and that employment stays “at-will.” These disclaimers can help shield a company in court — but they’re not a bulletproof vest.
If a company says one thing and consistently does another, that creates a problem. Courts will look at actions just as closely as words. And if a handbook promises detailed disciplinary steps (“you’ll receive three written warnings before any termination action”), that promise could easily be held up as enforceable.
Consistency is the golden rule. An employer who follows handbook procedures for most employees but ignores them when firing one unlucky soul could be signaling discrimination or retaliation, even without realizing it.
Real-World Situations Employers Want to Avoid
Think of Dave, an engineer at a large manufacturing firm. The handbook says employees must be given two warnings before suspension. Dave makes one mistake, and boom — he’s fired. His coworker, a longtime golfing buddy of the boss, makes the same mistake twice and only gets a gentle slap on the wrist. Dave’s attorney would probably have a field day with that.
Or picture Maria, a single mom who’s terminated after reporting unsafe working conditions. Her company claims her firing was “performance-related,” but she was never written up, warned, or placed on a performance plan. That smells strongly of wrongful termination tied to public policy — a claim courts in California take very seriously.
What Employees Can Actually Do
If you’re an employee and suspect your company violated its own disciplinary process, you aren’t powerless.
Start by gathering your paperwork. Dig up your offer letter, that employee handbook, any warning letters, emails — anything that shows a promised process. Then, find a qualified employment attorney to review the situation. You don’t have forever to act; wrongful termination claims often have strict time limits.
Winning a claim could mean back pay, front pay (future lost wages), compensation for emotional distress, or even punitive damages if the employer acted outrageously.
How Employers Can Protect Themselves
Employers hoping to avoid litigation nightmares should stay sharp. Here’s what savvy companies are doing:
- Writing clear, updated handbooks with strong disclaimers
- Training managers to apply discipline procedures consistently
- Rigorously following outlined steps when disciplining or firing employees
- Keeping thorough documentation for every disciplinary action
- Regularly revisiting policies to ensure they reflect current employment laws
Ultimately, when a company acts predictably and fairly, they not only protect themselves legally but also build a stronger, more respectful workplace culture.
Final Thoughts
Sandra’s story — and the stories of so many others — show that discipline procedures aren’t just dry policies written for HR binders. They carry real consequences. In a state like California, where workers’ rights are fiercely protected but employers’ rights are equally valued, fairness is the true currency.
Skipping steps or playing favorites isn’t just bad management — it could be a one-way ticket to a courtroom. For businesses, partnering with legal experts like California Business Lawyer & Corporate Lawyer Inc. or The Nakase Law Firm ensures that internal policies aren’t just words on paper, but a shield against unnecessary risk.
In the end, following your own rules is more than good practice — it’s the law.
Please be advised this article is for informational purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for advice from a trained legal or divorce professional. Please seek the advice of a legal or professional if you’re facing legal/law issues.
Full disclosure: She Owns It partners with others through contributor posts, affiliate links, and sponsored content. We are compensated for sponsored content. The views and opinions expressed reflect those of our guest contributor or sponsor. We have evaluated the links and content to the best of our ability at this time to make sure they meet our guidelines. As links and information evolve, we ask that readers do their due diligence, research, and consult with professionals as needed. If you have questions or concerns about any content published on our site, please let us know. We strive to only publish ethical content that supports our community. Thank you for supporting the brands that support this blog.